Sunday, August 28, 2011

The Guru's BlogPoll (2011 Preseason)

The Guru is back for a third season as a BlogPoll voter. Here's my 2011 preseason ballot, with a few notes below:


* I anointed Oklahoma as the top team for 2011 as soon as the 2010 season was over, and so far, have been given no reason to change that view. OU's schedule is very favorable for a title run, with only a road game at Florida State as a test among nonconference games and a weak and downsized Big 12 to slog through. And oh, no conference title game to serve as a last-gasp obstacle.

* LSU is moved down only slightly on my ballot after Jordan Jefferson's arrest. I believe the Tigers would not beat Oregon in Arlington even with Jefferson, so this essentially made no difference. Oregon had been my No. 2 team all along.

* South Carolina is my dark horse to play for the BCS title. The Gamecocks have a favorable schedule (no Alabma, no LSU) and get Florida at home. Of all the top teams in the SEC, the 'Cocks have by far the most negotiable path to the conference title game.

* Nebraska may well win the Big Ten in its first year in the league, but mostly because of the turmoil at Ohio State. But the Buckeyes should still have enough talent to make it to the inaugural Big Ten championship game.

* Utah, likewise, will win at least its division in the first year of the Pac-12. The Utes don't play either Oregon or Stanford, the two teams expected to dominate the Pac-12 North, in the regular season. So look for a title game matchup between the Utes and the Oregon-Stanford winner.

* Notre Dame will not be in a BCS bowl. You can take that to the bank. The Irish could be out of the BCS picture before the end of the September. The best-case scenario for ND is a 9-3 season, which won't be enough to get into a BCS bowl.

* Conference-by-conference tally: SEC (6, including 3 in top 10), Big Ten (5), Pac-12 (4), Big 12 (3), ACC (2), Mountain West (2), Big East (1), Conference USA (1) and one independent (Notre Dame).

Saturday, August 27, 2011

Alabama Opens 2011 as BCS No. 1

Oklahoma may be the consensus No. 1 in preseason polls, but on the strength of computer rankings, Alabama will open the 2011 season as the top team in the simulated BCS standings.

Using the same methodology as we've done in the past four seasons, we put together two human polls (Coaches Poll and AP Poll, replacing the Harris Poll), three of the six BCS computer rankings and the median ranking of 34 computers for our simulated BCS standings.




The Tide came out on top thanks to their superior computer scores (No. 1 in Sagarin, No. 3 in Massey and No. 2 in median rankings), whereas the Sooners' edge in the two human polls isn't enough to offset their middling computer scores. Oregon checks in as a close third, ranking third in both human polls and in the top 3 in all four computer rankings used.

In all, a record eight SEC teams are in the preseason top 25, followed by five teams from the Big 12 and four from the Big Ten. The Big East barely squeezed into the top 25, with West Virginia checking in at No. 24. Two non-BCS teams are also in the top 25 as Mountain West members Boise State (No. 5) and TCU (No. 11) will make another run to crash the BCS party.

Per BCS's rules, USC is not included in the rankings because the Trojans are serving the second year of their two-year bowl ban.
Google